Yesterday, I gave you my projected A.L. All-Star roster that can be found down below this post. Today with the final voting update being released for the National League, let’s see if I can figure out what the N.L. roster will look like. I’m really glad that Tony LaRussa retired and has a ton of time on his hands to figure out the roster, because this thing is pretty tough. Especially trying to put a Padres representative on the team.
Starter: Buster Posey, Giants
Reserves: Yadier Molina, Cardinals and Carlos Ruiz, Phillies
This will be a close battle all the way to the end as Molina may still end up starting the game. Posey could be in danger of not making the game if not named the starter as Molina and Ruiz are the two clear-cut top catchers this season. LaRussa could decide that two catchers are enough and go with an extra back-up somewhere else.
Starter: Joey Votto, Reds
Reserve: Martin Prado, Braves
This is where I had to get creative. No offensive position has gone without a backup since Derrek Lee in 2005 for the N.L. In that game, Morgan Ensberg who was designated as a 3B moved over to replace Lee in the game. In 2002, Alfonso Soriano was the only 2B for the American League and Omar Vizquel switched over from SS to play 2B. There is precedent to not have a backup 1B and I don’t think there should be. The only one I can make a case for is the Diamondbacks Paul Goldschmidt, but it would be bad if he becomes Arizona’s lone representative over a deserving Wade Miley. Prado is a versatile player that plays outfield, third base, and first base for the Braves. He’s a deserving All-Star, but N.L. outfield is so deep (we’ll get to that soon) that this is a way to get Prado on the team. I’m still figuring out why there are 873,526 wasted votes on Ryan Howard who hasn’t played this season.
Starter: Dan Uggla, Braves
Reserve: Jose Altuve, Astros
Uggla has fallen off hitting just .179 in the month of June, but Braves fans have continued to vote for him. He has a healthy lead on Brandon Phillips going into the final stage of voting. Altuve has been a find for the Astros hitting over .300 and being 5th in the league in hits. Phillips gets bumped to the Final Vote as the only infielder represented.
Starter: Rafael Furcal, Cardinals
Reserve: Starlin Castro, Cubs
The injury woes of Troy Tulowitzki will allow Furcal to make his 3rd All-Star team in 13 seasons and it’s deserved. Furcal looked done after last season, but has bounced back to hit .287 and be solid atop the Cardinals lineup. Castro is the Cubs lone representative for the 2nd straight year. Pretty impressive for a 22 year-old.
Starter: David Wright, Mets
Reserves: Chipper Jones, Braves and David Freese, Cardinals
I’ve made it clear previously that I think that Chipper Jones should be starting the All-Star Game in his final season. Here’s my solution. The National League will need a designated hitter, so who better than Chipper Jones? He could have his moment like Cal Ripken did in 2001 and David Wright still gets to start at 3B like he deserves. I’m sure Chipper’s knees would also appreciate not having to play the field. Freese has been solid for the Cardinals as he’s top 10 in the league in HR’s and RBI. I’m sure LaRussa will bring him along after his postseason heroics in 2011.
Starters: Matt Kemp, Dodgers, Carlos Beltran, Cardinals, and Ryan Braun, Brewers
Reserves: Melky Cabrera, Giants, Carlos Gonzalez, Rockies, Andrew McCutchen, Pirates, Giancarlo Stanton, Marlins and Andre Ethier, Dodgers
This is by far the deepest position in all of the Majors. Not making the team includes Michael Bourn, Matt Holliday and Hunter Pence who have all been fantastic. Mike Trout was able to make my A.L. squad, but the deepness at the position here blocks Bryce Harper from making the initial squad at 19 years old. There is still a tight battle for the final starting spot between Braun and Cabrera, but both will make the team. Gonzalez and Stanton are being snubbed by voters, but will be the solo representatives for the Rockies and Marlins respectively. Ethier sneaks in the final outfield spot as he’s helped keep the Dodgers afloat in Matt Kemp’s absence. Kemp’s injury will hopefully open up an extra spot for Bourn, Holliday, or Pence.
Starter: R.A. Dickey, Mets
Reserves: Stephen Strasburg, Nationals, Matt Cain, Giants, Gio Gonzalez, Nationals, Wade Miley, Diamondbacks, Johnny Cueto, Reds, James McDonald, Pirates, Lance Lynn, Cardinals, Chris Capuano, Dodgers, and Clayton Kershaw, Dodgers
The battle to be the starting pitcher couldn’t be any closer between Dickey, Strasburg, and Cain. I just think that Dickey is such a wonderful story that it would be amazing to have him start the game, so I gave him the edge. My American League roster had eight starters, but there are so many options in the N.L. that I upped it to ten. Even that wasn’t enough as Cole Hamels and Zack Greinke get snubbed. I believe that LaRussa will err on the side of the Cardinals and take Lance Lynn for the last pitching spot. Wade Miley is rightfully Arizona’s only representative.
Reserves: Craig Kimbrel, Braves, Aroldis Chapman, Reds, and Huston Street, Padres
Kimbrel has been lights out all season. Chapman had been perfect up until recently, but they are the two fireballers that the senior circuit needs to close out the game. Street goes to the game because I couldn’t figure out another way to get a Padre on the roster. I couldn’t have Carlos Quentin take a spot from one of the outfielders, Chase Headley over David Freese, or have Yonder Alonso be the back-up 1B. Street missed time with an injury, but has a 1.50 ERA and 0.78 ERA when healthy this season.
Michael Bourn, Braves, Cole Hamels, Phillies, Brandon Phillips, Reds, Matt Holliday, Cardinals, and Bryce Harper, Nationals
When I originally wrote out my roster Harper making the Final Vote didn’t even cross my mind. Then I had an epiphany, there is no way MLB doesn’t put Harper in, just to stir up some excitement for it. There are great voting fan bases represented in this final vote and I sadly couldn’t put in Zack Greinke. Greinke and Hamels will hopefully make the team on the “pitcher pitching Sunday” rule. Bourn has been wonderful leading off the Braves lineup and is among the league leaders in WAR. Brandon Phillips might make the All-Star game as a starter still, but him being in the Final Vote let’s him use his social media skills to the fullest.
Dodgers and Braves-4
Giants and Reds-3
Mets, Nationals, and Pirates-2
Diamondbacks, Padres, Rockies, Cubs, Brewers, Astros, Phillies, and Marlins-1
Unlike the American League, I feel like there are a ton of snubs on my National League team. Joel Hanrahan, Tyler Clippard, Kenley Jansen, Zack Greinke, Hunter Pence, Ryan Vogelsong, and Jed Lowrie just to name a few. Who would make your National League roster? Let me know in the comments!
-Bryan Mapes (@IAmMapes)
Each year, 68 Major League Baseball players (34 from each league) descend upon a pre-determined city to wear tacky uniforms and watch their friends and teammates hit ridiculous home runs. This year, it is Kansas City’s turn to host the All-Star Game.
And as with every year, there are more than 68 deserving players. Even more intriguing sometimes than the players who do make it to the All-Star Game are the ones who got snubbed.
With the game determining home-field advantage for the World Series (one of the worst rules ever created in any game anywhere…ever), stakes have been raised in recent years. Still, with fan vote factoring in and the inevitable, biased manager’s choices to fill out the rosters, players are going to get snubbed.
Here are five guaranteed snubs of this year’s All-Star Game from each league, ten in total:
1. A.J. Ellis, C, Los Angeles Dodgers
Ellis has handled the Majors’ 2nd-best pitching staff flawlessly to this point in the season, and has kept his average fluttering around .330. The most impressive stat that the National League squad will miss out on is his ability to get to 1st base. As of play today, Ellis has racked up an astounding .444 on-base percentage.
The crop of deserving N.L. catchers is just too large this season. You have to think Yadier Molina (St. Louis) and Buster Posey (San Francisco) will make it on fan vote alone. And I can’t see Carlos Ruiz of Philadelphia being snubbed, which leaves no room for the quietest great catcher of the season. Lucroy’s line right now: .343/5/29/.386.
3. James McDonald, SP, Pittsburgh Pirates
Erik Bedard is getting a ton of credit for his comeback performance in the rotation this season, and deservedly so. But the guy nobody is talking about is the electric righty who has finally put all his talent together into one unhittable package. One that won’t be making the All-Star Game, despite a 2.51 ERA, 0.99 WHIP and .198 batting average against.
4. Anthony Bass, SP, San Diego Padres
Three Up, Three Down’s first MLB player to join the podcast has been stellar since joining the rotation in San Diego. Aside from two hiccups, he’s allowed 3 ER or less in all of his starts in 2012. In 54.1 innings as a starter in 2012, Bass has given up just 22 earned runs. Unfortunately, his run support hasn’t been all that great, so his record doesn’t reflect his performance.
5. Bryan LaHair, 1B, Chicago Cubs
LaHair was a sight to behold for the first month of this season. He’s cooled off considerably, which won’t help him get to Kansas City. Not only is the poor guy going to miss the All-Star Game even with a .301/10/21/.397 line, but he’ll probably lose his starting spot to Anthony Rizzo as soon as the Cubs call him up. I hope LaHair can play outfield!
1. Fernando Rodney, RP, Tampa Bay Rays
David Price is going to get the Rays’ guaranteed All-Star bid, and James Shields might sneak in as well. That leaves the most dominant closer in baseball to this point (you read that right), wondering what he could have done better to get to K.C. It’s a popularity contest, and there just won’t be room for poor Fernando and his 15 saves or 0.38 ERA.
2. Jason Hammel, SP, Baltimore Orioles
I can’t imagine anyone besides Jim Johnson and Adam Jones (who are absolute locks) going to the All-Star Game from the first-place O’s. Despite a ridiculously hot start to the season, Hammel is going to be squeezed out by pitchers like C.C. Sabathia, Yu Darvish and Felix Hernandez. Poor guy. His 6-1 record and 2.78 ERA is going to waste.
3. Derek Lowe, SP, Cleveland Indians
How about D-Lowe this year? The old man still has some nasty sinkerballs in him, and he’s showing it. Lowe has been the veteran anchor on a first-place Cleveland staff, but we all know this kind of success won’t last; ask a Braves fan. Just because we know it’s a fluke, doesn’t mean Lowe and his 6-2 record and 2.15 ERA are any less deserving of a spot.
This may be the biggest snub of them all, but nobody knows who Cook is outside of Oakland. His 0.00 ERA so far in 22.2 innings is incredible, as is his 21 K’s, 4 hits allowed and 0.78 WHIP. But how is Cook going to be selected over Jim Johnson, Jonathan Broxton and Chris Perez for the bullpen? This may be the first time ever a pitcher who hasn’t allowed a first-half run gets snubbed.
5. Billy Butler, 1B, Kansas City Royals
Sigh. What a shame. Playing in his team’s stadium, no less. But you’ve got to understand that the American League DH spot is going to David Ortiz, and the first baseman slots will be filled by Albert Pujols, Prince Fielder and Adrian Gonzalez. Don’t forget, this is still a popularity contest. Butler has been the best of the bunch at .292/9/32, but he may need the Final Vote to get the spot he deserves.
Who else do you think will be snubbed? Let me know in the comments below! Also, is the home-field advantage rule stupid? Comment away!
– Jeremy Dorn (@Jamblinman)